After the two shocking events I wrote about
yesterday – election of Trump and demonetisation of 500/1000 rupee notes in
India – my mind is searching for answers, which are hard to come by. My post
about the latter has invited a lot of comments from friends and trolls,
praising the PM for his bold move, overnight transformation of the economy, et
al. A lot of people are put to needless harassment and loss and people in
well-paying jobs are saying: it’s for the good, so grin and bear it. So, you, urban
middle-class office workers, what do you know about the rural villager who has
to walk a few kilometres to the nearest bank, and, when there, he is handicapped
as he doesn’t know how to fill in a form? We are living in frightening times
where every day brings some new revelations, or, news of revelations not made. Therefore,
here are some rambling thoughts on democracy and development.
When you dig deeper, you find that the
malady lies buried down in several layers of a deep gorge of misdeeds in this
unipolar world. Is there a disregard for democratic norms? Is there a lack of
proper understanding of how democracy works? Was democratic institutions
compromised? Is the one who is better at compromising democratic norms the
winner in an election? If so, what have we done to safeguard democracy? Is communism
the better alternative, in a world where the world’s leading communist
countries have turned capitalists with a vengeance?
It’s a fearful world we inhabit. First let
me deal with the election of Trump to the highest office of the world. There
were allegations of Russians having hacked into Clinton’s emails. It’s quite
possible. Maybe, even Clinton had rigged the Democratic nomination to be the
nominee. As I said it’s a fearful and distressful world we inhabit. The winner could
be the one who knows how to subvert the democratic process. As the Wikileaks
revelations reveal the world is not a safe place for governments and
corporations anymore. However, the Wikileaks revelations came too late, didn’t
it? By the time it came out everything was over. Anything could happen today.
We are probably experiencing the first shocks of this horrid future as
demonstrated by recent incidents.
There’s no doubt that the America (By
America I mean the U.S.A.) that stands for truth and democracy may be truly
compromising its democratic ideals. To get ahead it is willing to sacrifice anything,
as Obama’s support for fracking and the Keystone pipe line shows. Around the
world also, America says it has interests, meaning private business interests,
not interest of a free and democratic world. The point is, America is no longer
interested in propagating its democratic ideology, nor is the leadership here
in India, as seen by the oppression of minorities in recent times.
In its quest to be a world economic leader,
China has created one of the biggest commercial-industrial complexes in the
world, leading to pollution of its air, water, and cities. We have to ask
ourselves if this is the development we want and aspire for. Our present
dispensation wants to follow the path shown by China, i.e., development at all
costs: smart cities, superfast trains, industrial corridors, exploitation of
earth for minerals, etc. There are some pitfalls here, which we aren’t aware
of.
After plundering its countryside for coal, iron,
copper, gold, and bauxite, China is aggressively seeking mining licences in
Africa and less developed economies. At the forefront of development, China is
today the world’s largest economy and is increasingly being belligerent militarily
also. And, discreetly, America and Russia are partners in China’s growth.
Meanwhile, the vast military-industrial
complex in America keeps wars going on in Asia and other parts because it’s in
their interest to do so. There used to be a sacrosanct rule that militaries
will not attack civilian targets and places where people lived. These days,
wars are going on in city neighbourhoods putting the women and children there
to unnecessary trauma as the wars in Homs, Aleppo, and Mosul in Syria show. Soldiers
and militia-men are pictured blasting whole towns and neighbourhoods.
America is perhaps one of the few countries
where arms can be manufactured and exported to foreign countries freely. There is
the Arms Export Control Act (AECA) by which the President can stop export of
arms, but it’s rarely enforced, because, as often seen, the President himself acts
as the salesman for American arms. There are curbs on exporting arms to groups
who are of an extremist ideology, but these rules are conveniently overlooked. The
military-industrial complex and its lobbyists see that the flow of arms to even
extreme groups is maintained.
In India, when we have development as the
foremost ideal to generate jobs, we tend to overlook the pitfalls into which
America and China fell. We are following them in the mad scramble for
development, giving mining rights in our pristine lands to Chinese
corporations, buying arms from America, and generally revelling in our new friendship
with America. But, do not forget, America only has interests, meaning business interests.
Once this is kept aside America will consider India on par with Pakistan, even
favour the latter.
America is a big user of biotechnology. Many
believe that biotechnology is an advancement of science and its use can alleviate
world hunger. In fact, this fallacy has no basis in truth. Genetically modified
organisms (GMOs) may give marginally increased production for a few years, but
take a heavy toll on the soil on which cultivation is done. The pesticides that
form a part of GMO-based cultivation have been proved to cause cancer and birth
defects. American corporations have used biotechnology with disastrous results
in the developing world, spreading poisonous pesticides, giving birth to
mentally-challenged children, and increasing the number of sick people in the
world.
The powerful GMO lobby in the US can bend
laws to their advantage, and appoint chairmen to the Federal Drug
Administration (FDA) which regulates biotechnology. Over the years, it has been
found that top executives of GMO companies are appointed as chairmen of FDA because,
ironically, they are experts and have the knowledge. They, in turn, turn a
blind eye to the doings of GMO corporations with the result that today harmful
carcinogens like Glyphosate are widely used in America. Obama assumed office
with the promise of labelling GMO products on their covers, but, as he remits
office, he has signed into law, a proposal that precludes the labelling of GMO
products.
The GMO lobby sees India as a big market
and is waiting to introduce their products through legislation in India. The danger
to India is that GMOs may be seen as bringing about development and, therefore,
adopted, as a part of the development agenda. So also is the condoning of the
demonetisation of 500/1000 rupee notes. It’s a part of development, isn’t it? It’s
because of the stiff fight put up by activists such as Vandana Shiva and others
that, so far, India hasn’t become a GMO-cultivating nation like Argentina. Argentina
has discovered, albeit late, that GMOs are harmful because of the increasing
cases of birth defects in its child population. Venezuela has totally banned GMO
products from the country, after its bitter experience with its usage. In India,
BT cotton is the only GMO product that has been approved for cultivation, and
has caused untold sufferings to farmers in Maharashtra and Andhra Pradesh.
More in the next instalment of “Random
Musings of a Solitary Walker.”